Holding Hands, Not Holding On: How to Support a Partner’s Insecurity Without Losing Yourself
Exploring the line between emotional support and self-sacrifice in non-monogamous relationships.
One of my clients recently asked:
“How can I help my partner navigate their own insecurities and vice versa? And at what point does that responsibility end or dissolve?”
It’s a beautiful question—one that cuts to the heart of relational care, especially in non-monogamous dynamics where old paradigms about ownership and emotional fusion are being challenged.
This is Part 1 of a two-part series exploring how to navigate insecurity in non-monogamous and polyamorous relationships with care and clarity. In this post, we’ll look at how to offer support without self-abandonment, what healthy emotional boundaries actually look like, and what supporting a partner is *not.*
(Usually, Q&As like this are reserved for paid subscribers—but I’m sharing this one as a freebie because we all deserve better tools for navigating insecurity and emotional growth in our relationships.)
Insecurity Is a Signal, Not a Flaw
In every relationship, insecurities are bound to surface. Sometimes they whisper, sometimes their roar wakes us in the night. They might sound like:
“What if they leave?”
“Am I enough?”
“Why do I feel so afraid when I do trust them?”
The truth is, insecurity is a human experience—not a personal failure. And when we're in a loving partnership, it's natural to want to support each other through these tender questions.
But how do we do that in a way that’s genuinely supportive—without becoming responsible for our partner’s emotional world?
Insecurity often points to deeper needs for safety, belonging, or reassurance. Sometimes it’s rooted in childhood wounds or past ruptures in the relationship that never fully healed. Other times, it’s a valid cue that something in the current dynamic needs attention.
The first step is acknowledging insecurity without shame or judgment. From there, it’s easier to show up with curiosity, compassion, and presence.
What Supporting a Partner Can Look Like
Listening deeply without trying to fix
Validating their emotions: “It makes sense you’d feel that way given what you’ve been through”
Offering grounded reassurance: “I care about you. I want to stay connected”
Being patient while they sit with discomfort
Clarifying boundaries and desires with care and clarity
How to Communicate When You’re the One Feeling Insecure
Letting yourself be seen in your insecurity—without shame or defensiveness—creates the conditions for true connection. Many of us try to play it cool by suppressing our fears or pretending we don’t need anything. But real intimacy comes from vulnerability.
The more we can practice bringing those tender feelings forward—owning our emotions rather than blaming our partner—the more likely we are to be met with the care and reassurance we truly need.
For example:
“I’m feeling insecure about how much you seem to be into this new person. Can you remind me why our connection still matters to you?”
That kind of openness invites closeness. It creates a space where reassurance can land, rather than triggering defensiveness or distance.
What Supporting a Partner Is Not
Silencing your own needs to manage theirs
Walking on eggshells to avoid triggering discomfort
Over-explaining or people-pleasing to ease their fear
Becoming their sole emotional regulator or therapist
When we take on full responsibility for another person’s emotional landscape, it quickly becomes codependency, not care. And that kind of self-abandonment isn’t sustainable.
The Dance of Co-Regulation and Self-Regulation
Healthy relationships require both. We co-regulate by offering presence, attunement, and care—but that only works when it's mutual and paired with self-regulation.
Think of it like a dance: you can extend your hand, but your partner has to choose to move with you. You can’t dance for them.
There’s a big difference between walking alongside someone through their insecurity and carrying them through it.
So, When Does the Responsibility End?
A partner’s role is to support, witness, and love—but not to fix, manage, or control. The line between support and self-sacrifice is often crossed when:
You feel resentment building
You’re suppressing your own needs to protect their feelings
They’re unwilling to reflect or grow
Your limits are not being honored, even after being expressed with care
At that point, stepping back is not punishment—it’s clarity. Because love isn’t about erasing each other’s pain. It’s about building enough trust and self-awareness to sit in it together, without losing ourselves in the process.
Up Next in Part Two: Differentiation & Emotional Boundaries in Non-Monogamy
In the next post, I’ll share one of my favorite communication tools—The Triple A Timeout—along with reflections on how differentiation helps us stay emotionally connected without merging. We’ll explore why this is especially important in open relationships, where time, attention, and energy don’t "belong" to one person—and why that’s both challenging and liberating.
Like what you’re reading? Buy Me A Coffee :)
If this resonated with you, consider becoming a paid subscriber. It’s just $8/month—the price of a single fancy latte—and it supports the emotional labor and care that goes into these weekly articles.
Want support navigating relationship triggers in real time?
For a limited time I’m offering free Trigger Mapping Calls—a free 1:1 session where we’ll slow down together and gently explore what’s coming up for you in moments of reactivity, fear, or overwhelm. Using somatic tools and relational insight, we’ll identify the deeper needs beneath the trigger and map a compassionate path forward towards more ease, joy and abundant connection.